Strategic Withdrawals for Higher Education

For families, few financial goals blend emotion and strategy quite like paying for college. Yet even for more affluent households, the question remains: what is the most effective way to withdraw funds for tuition?

For advisors, these conversations often arise when education costs or plans shift in ways clients didn’t anticipate—such as a student pursuing a post-doctorate degree that won’t be fully covered with remaining 529 funds, or a beneficiary being accepted to their high-priced dream school. In these cases, advisors must think strategically about how to coordinate withdrawals across multiple sources. When the 529 plan isn’t the only source of education funding, the objective is not simply to cover costs, but to create a plan that preserves liquidity, minimizes taxes, and avoids unnecessary interest expense.

At the center of any well-designed education payment strategy sits the 529 plan. While grants, scholarships, loans, and direct payments all have their place, the 529 plan often provides the organizing framework that guides when and from where education dollars should be drawn.

Start with Scholarships and Grants (Free Money First) to Preserve 529 Assets

The most efficient withdrawal sequence always begins with sources that don’t need to be repaid. Grants and scholarships—whether merit-based, need-based, or tied to a particular field of study—represent the foundation of educational capital. For high net-worth families, these awards may not change the affordability equation, but they serve an important strategic purpose. Every dollar earned through scholarship support is a dollar that doesn’t need to be withdrawn, borrowed, or liquidated from other sources.

Families should file the FAFSA and, if required, the CSS Profile, even if they believe they won’t qualify, as these forms can unlock merit-based, need-based, and institutional aid.¹ Beyond submitting the paperwork, it’s important to engage directly with schools to explore ways to reduce tuition or increase scholarship awards. Many don’t realize the cost of tuition can be negotiated, even after scholarships are offered. They may also offer work-study programs that provide an additional option for students to contribute toward expenses while gaining valuable experience.

Many colleges have flexibility in awarding aid, particularly for academically strong applicants, students with unique talents—such as in music, dance, or sports—or those experiencing financial changes. Families can request reconsideration if circumstances change or if competing offers are received. Colleges and programs may also offer awards or tuition discounts based on residency, academics, career path, or community service. Private scholarships from local organizations or online platforms, such as Scholarships.com or the College Board Scholarship Search, can further offset costs. It is estimated that close to $100 million in scholarships and around $2 billion in student grants go unclaimed every year, primarily due to lack of applicants.²

This supplemental funding is especially beneficial when looking at 529s as it allows more time for tax-free compounding. Over four years (or across generations), that deferral can meaningfully increase the long-term value of the account.

What Is the Best 529 Withdrawal Strategy for College Funding?

After scholarships and grants, the next step is to determine how and when to tap the 529 plan, which typically serves as the most tax-efficient and strategically flexible source of education funding.

Earnings within a 529 grow tax-deferred, and withdrawals used for qualified education expenses are free from federal income tax. However, the advantages extend far beyond simple tax savings. A well-structured 529 can function as a multigenerational education endowment, supporting not just one student, but multiple. Parents and grandparents can contribute while remaining within annual gift tax exclusions, effectively transferring wealth in a tax-efficient manner. The ability to “superfund” a plan by contributing up to five years’ worth of the annual exclusion at once accelerates growth and allows assets to compound earlier.

Because 529 assets are both tax-advantaged and dedicated to education, they often represent the most practical source of funding for the first phase of college expenses. Drawing from the 529 in the early years helps avoid the buildup of loan interest later, while preserving liquidity in other investment or taxable accounts. Each family’s situation will differ based on total assets and cash flow, but in many cases, using 529 funds to cover costs provides an optimal balance—minimizing borrowing needs and reducing exposure to market volatility that could affect the timing or value of future withdrawals.

Yet each family’s situation is unique. In some cases, delaying 529 withdrawals in favor of paying directly from cash reserves or investments may better align with broader financial goals, risk tolerance, or portfolio strategy.

Should You Use 529 Funds or Pay Out-of-Pocket First?

Ultimately, families can approach 529 withdrawals and direct payments in either order depending on their circumstances. For example, if paying directly from a bank account, writing a check is straightforward and may make sense before tapping 529 funds. But if the alternative is selling investments, then taxes and potential capital gains come into play, making the decision more complex.

Many families pay some education costs directly, either from income or cash reserves. This approach offers simplicity and avoids the administrative complexity of loans or staged distributions, but timing and sequencing still matter.

Liquidating investments may trigger capital gains, shift portfolio allocations, or limit flexibility for other goals. In some cases, preserving invested assets may be the more efficient choice, particularly when their expected long-term return may exceed expected short-term returns in strategies within the 529 plan. The optimal decision depends on the family’s broader financial picture, tax position, and tolerance for market risk.

Coordinating withdrawals with portfolio management and cash-flow planning ensures that education funding decisions remain integrated within the family’s overall wealth strategy. The essential point is to view “cutting a check” not simply as a payment, but as part of a coordinated wealth strategy that balances tax efficiency, liquidity, and the preservation of investment capital over time.

When Do Student Loans Make Sense in a College Funding Strategy?

Loans should only be considered after all other funding sources—scholarships, grants, savings, and 529 assets—have been fully utilized. Even federal loans, which offer fixed interest rates and deferred repayment, create long-term financial obligations and accrue interest from the moment they are disbursed. The Federal Direct Unsubsidized Loan program allows eligible students to borrow up to $20,500 per year³, usually at a rate that is lower than private alternatives, but repayment begins after graduation, adding to the student’s debt load. Because the rate is fixed and backed by the federal government, these loans often represent the least expensive form of borrowing available.

Private loans, by contrast, should generally be last in line. Their variable rates and stricter terms make them even less favorable. Because of these factors, private loans should only be considered when no other options remain and should never form the core of an education funding strategy.

Loan obligations can quickly accumulate and exceed federal limits, creating additional financial risk. By prioritizing scholarships, grants, and 529 assets first, families can minimize borrowing, reduce interest costs, and avoid the long-term burden that loans impose.

How Does College Funding Fit into a Broader Wealth Strategy?

Paying for higher education is not a one-time decision but an evolving strategy that should be revisited each year as expenses, financial aid, and market conditions change. The optimal plan balances immediate cost savings with long-term financial efficiency. For families with significant resources, the key is to sequence funding sources intentionally: prioritize free money, leverage tax-advantaged assets, preserve liquidity where appropriate, and borrow only if truly needed.

An organized, tax-aware funding plan not only reduces the total cost of education but also integrates seamlessly with broader wealth management goals. In doing so, it ensures that supporting a child’s education does not compromise the family’s long-term financial legacy.

Access exclusive tools and content

Obtain exclusive insights, CE courses, events, model allocations and portfolio analytics powered by Aladdin® technology.

Get access now