ACTIVE INVESTING INSIGHTS

One hot economy, two burning questions on value and income

May 11, 2021
  • BlackRock

The switch on the U.S. economy is readying to come fully “on,” more than a year after the global pandemic forced abrupt closures around the world and across industries.

The restart could be unlike any we’ve seen in nearly 40 years, says Tony DeSpirito, CIO of U.S. Fundamental Equities. It is being fueled by unprecedented fiscal and monetary policy, a productive vaccine program, pent-up demand for products and services after months of lockdown, and consumer balance sheets that are uniquely strong after a recession.

Whereas households typically need to repair their finances after an economic downturn, Mr. DeSpirito observes that balance sheets have improved throughout this crisis as individuals saved during lockdown and paid down debt. The upshot is more sidelined cash waiting to be unleashed.

All of this is putting major thrust behind the U.S. economy, raising some critical questions for forward-thinking investors.

Value’s fate

Have recovery-fueled value stocks exhausted their outperformance potential?

Value stocks, as measured by the Russell 1000 Value Index, lagged in the throes of the crisis but have outperformed their growth counterparts by more than 15% since the announcement of the first effective vaccine in November of 2020. It’s been a big move in a short time, but Mr. DeSpirito believes the value run still has legs.

The experience in prior recessions shows that value has outperformed for two years coming out of the downturn. At only six months in and the economy yet to fully open, Mr. DeSpirito sees further runway, even as the return in this early recovery has matched the average of the 24 months following prior recessions. See the chart below.

Value historically has dominated post-recession
Value stocks’ excess return over broad index, 24 months after recession bear market

Value historically has dominated post-recession

Source: BlackRock, with data from IDC and IBES. IBES earnings per share (EPS) estimates are used in calculating the forward earnings yield. Data is analyzed from Dec. 31, 1978, to March 31, 2021, and the graph depicts the last five bear market periods that coincided with a recession. Bear markets defined as peak-to-trough stock price decline of 20% or more; recession periods as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research. “Recession bear market” periods reflect monthly observations over the course of a recession-related bear market. Excess return of value stocks is calculated using the equal-weighted return for the top quintile of Russell 1000 stocks by earnings yield, rebalanced monthly, less the equal-weighted return for the Russell 1000 Index. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of current or future results. It is not possible to invest directly in an index.

His confidence stems from two key metrics:

  • Inflation-era outperformance. A Fundamental Equities analysis of inflation data from 1927 to 2020 found that value equities have outperformed their growth counterparts by the widest margin in periods of moderate to high inflation. Mr. DeSpirito is not forecasting a sustained rise in inflation in the near-term, but the prevailing economic momentum is sure to seed inflation in the medium- to longer-term  and that should give the value cycle further longevity.
  • A valuation discrepancy. DeSpirito and team also analyzed valuation spreads – the difference in price-to-earnings ratios for the cheapest stocks (value) versus the average U.S. stock. While the disparity in valuation has narrowed from a historic wide back in November, it was still far from “normal” at March 31 – at nearly two standard deviations wider than the average observed since 1979.

“In prior recoveries, we’ve seen this gap not only narrow to the average, but actually become smaller than the average. We have a way to go on that score.”

Mr. DeSpirito acknowledges this cycle has and can continue to be unlike any other. Change could come quickly, and that has him looking for opportunities to shift from a focus on more deeply discounted cyclical value (a shrinking group as the market recovers) to a quality value focus. This would include stocks with a history of dividend growth and lower relative volatility, an important consideration in a low-rate world.

The income imperative

As the economy boils and rates normalize higher, where is the income opportunity?

Michael Fredericks, Head of Income Investing for BlackRock’s Multi-Asset Strategies and Solutions team, shares his equity counterpart’s affinity for dividend stocks, and sees a particular opportunity after the valuations of high-dividend stocks were beaten down last year. He cites the potential for company dividends to grow across time as a benefit versus bond coupons, which are very low and fixed to maturity.

Mr. Fredericks cites the acceleration in economic growth as another reason to question the role of traditional bonds in a portfolio, as rising bond yields mean falling bond prices. He is cautious on investment grade bonds, mortgages and the quality parts of fixed income that make up the Bloomberg-Barclays Aggregate Bond Index.

The pandemic-fueled flight to quality helped “the Agg” deliver a return of 7.5% in 2020, but it has lost 2.6% through April of this year as interest rates and inflation have risen and investors have grown more comfortable adding risk to their portfolios. If interest rates continue to grind higher, as Mr. Fredericks expects, higher-quality bonds may continue to struggle.

While he doesn’t see the 10-year Treasury yield approaching 3% anytime soon, the kind of rate that might make U.S. Treasuries appear more attractive relative to higher-risk assets, Mr. Fredericks still sees prudence in maintaining low duration (or interest rate risk).

His favored income engines are preferred stock, high yield bonds and bank loans. The latter are particularly interesting given they are higher in a company’s capital structure and have a low correlation to equity moves. Bank loans currently trade at a discount to par, offering some capital appreciation potential in addition to yields in the area of 4%.

In addition to dividend stocks, Mr. Fredericks also likes equity covered calls  a strategy of owning a stock and giving away potential gains beyond a pre-determined level. This, he says, is another way to generate attractive yield while allowing for upside participation should stocks continue to move higher.

A fine time to get active

Both Mr. DeSpirito and Mr. Fredericks are active investors, an attribute they believe gives them the agility to navigate a cycle that could be as fast on the upturn as it was on the downturn.

The period we’re entering will require active shifts in the investment playbook, Mr. DeSpirito says.

“We have to think of the world differently in the next few years,” Mr. Fredericks adds. “There will be anxiety, but as active investors, we have the flexibility to seek out yield in a yield-starved world without taking huge risk.”

“Active adds value,” he concludes, a statement both are eager to deliver on as the world embraces post-pandemic growth.

Tony DeSpirito
Tony DeSpirito
BlackRock Fundamental Active Equity Investment Team
Antonio (Tony) DeSpirito, Managing Director, is Chief Investment Officer of U.S. Fundamental Active Equity. He is also lead portfolio manager of the BlackRock Equity ...
Michael Fredericks
Michael Fredericks
Head of Income Investing for BlackRock Multi-Asset Strategies Team
Michael Fredericks, Managing Director, is head of Income Investing for the BlackRock Multi-Asset Strategies & Solutions group and lead portfolio manager for the ...