Financially fit

Retirement withdrawal rules and strategies

Retirement withdrawal strategies can affect retirement income, taxes, portfolio longevity, and spending flexibility. Common approaches include the 4% rule, fixed-dollar withdrawals, fixed-percentage withdrawals, systematic withdrawals, and bucket strategies. Retirees should also consider required minimum distributions (RMDs), inflation, and the tax treatment of withdrawals from traditional and Roth retirement accounts.

Key takeaways

  • 01

    Understand retirement withdrawal rules

    Penalty-free withdrawals from many retirement accounts, including 401(k)s and IRAs, generally begin at age 59½. Required minimum distributions (RMDs) typically begin at age 73, and early withdrawals may trigger taxes and penalties.

  • 02

    Compare retirement withdrawal strategies

    Common retirement withdrawal strategies include fixed-dollar withdrawals, fixed-percentage withdrawals, and systematic withdrawal approaches. Each strategy affects retirement income, portfolio longevity, and flexibility differently.

  • 03

    Consider the tax impact of withdrawals

    Withdrawals from traditional retirement accounts are generally taxed as ordinary income, while qualified Roth withdrawals are typically tax-free. Tax-efficient withdrawal planning may help retirees manage income and reduce lifetime tax exposure.

Understanding retirement withdrawal rules

Most retirement accounts, including 401(k) plans, 403(b) plans, and traditional individual retirement accounts (IRAs), allow penalty-free withdrawals beginning at age 59½. Early withdrawals may trigger a 10% additional tax penalty unless an IRS exception applies.

Some retirement withdrawals are mandatory. Required minimum distributions (RMDs) generally begin at age 73 for certain tax-deferred retirement accounts, although the starting age is scheduled to increase to 75 in 2033. RMDs apply to many traditional retirement accounts, while Roth IRAs and Roth 401(k)s are generally exempt during the original account owner’s lifetime.

Withdrawals from traditional retirement accounts are generally taxed as ordinary income, while qualified withdrawals from Roth accounts are typically tax-free. Tax-efficient withdrawal planning may help retirees better manage retirement income and lifetime tax exposure.

Choosing a retirement withdrawal strategy

A safe retirement withdrawal rate is the percentage of retirement savings a retiree may be able to withdraw annually while aiming to make retirement assets last throughout retirement. Many retirees use the 4% rule as a starting framework, although sustainable withdrawal rates vary based on market performance, inflation, taxes, spending needs, and retirement length.

Retirees may choose different withdrawal strategies depending on income needs, market conditions, and spending flexibility. Common approaches include the 4% rule, fixed-dollar withdrawals, fixed-percentage withdrawals, and systematic withdrawal strategies.

What is the 4% rule?

The 4% rule is a retirement withdrawal strategy in which retirees withdraw 4% of retirement savings during the first year of retirement and then adjust future withdrawals annually for inflation.

Many retirees value the 4% rule because it can provide a relatively predictable withdrawal framework. However, prolonged market downturns, inflation, and sequence-of-returns risk may affect portfolio longevity over time.

Why some retirees use the 4% rule

The 4% rule is designed to help retirees balance predictable retirement income with long-term portfolio sustainability. However, changing market conditions, inflation, and withdrawal timing may affect whether a 4% withdrawal rate remains sustainable throughout retirement.

Potential drawbacks of the 4% rule

The 4% rule may not fully account for changing market conditions, inflation, or individual spending needs. In particular, retiring during a prolonged market downturn could increase the risk of depleting retirement savings earlier than expected.

What are fixed-dollar withdrawals?

Some retirees take out a fixed-dollar amount over a specific period of time. For example, you might decide to withdraw $40,000 annually and then reassess the dollar amount at the end of a five-year period. While this provides predictable annual income (which can help you budget accordingly), it doesn’t do much to protect against inflation; and depending on the dollar amount you choose, you could erode your principal. Moreover, if your investments are down in value due to market volatility, you may need to sell more of your assets to meet your withdrawal needs.

Example of a 4% retirement withdrawal strategy

Under the 4% rule, a retiree with a $1 million retirement portfolio would withdraw approximately $40,000 during the first year of retirement. Future withdrawals are typically adjusted over time to account for inflation.

Bar chart illustrating a 4% retirement withdrawal strategy, showing annual withdrawals of $40,000 from a $1 million retirement portfolio over five years.

For illustrative purposes only.

Why some retirees use fixed-dollar withdrawals

Many retirees use fixed-dollar withdrawals because they provide a predictable income stream that can make budgeting and cash-flow planning easier. This approach may also simplify account administration, including tax withholding from retirement accounts.

Potential drawbacks of fixed-dollar withdrawals

Fixed-dollar withdrawals do not automatically adjust for inflation, which can reduce purchasing power over time. Additionally, during market downturns, maintaining the same withdrawal amount may require selling a larger portion of your investments, potentially increasing the risk of depleting savings.

What are fixed-percentage withdrawals?

A fixed-percentage withdrawal strategy involves withdrawing a set percentage of a retirement portfolio each year. Unlike fixed-dollar withdrawals, the withdrawal amount changes based on the portfolio’s market value and investment performance.

For example, a retiree with a $1 million portfolio who withdraws 4% annually would take out $40,000 during the first year. If the portfolio grows or declines over time, future withdrawal amounts would increase or decrease accordingly.

Some retirees use fixed-percentage withdrawals because the strategy automatically adjusts to changing market conditions. However, annual retirement income may fluctuate from year to year, which can make retirement budgeting less predictable.

Example of a fixed-percentage withdrawal strategy

Under a fixed-percentage withdrawal strategy, annual withdrawals rise or fall based on changes in portfolio value over time.

Bar chart illustrating a fixed-percentage retirement withdrawal strategy, with annual withdrawals varying from $39,156 to $44,496 over five years based on changes in portfolio value.

For illustrative purposes only.

Why some retirees use fixed-percentage withdrawals

Fixed-percentage withdrawals may help retirees preserve portfolio longevity because withdrawals adjust alongside investment performance. This strategy may also reduce the risk of withdrawing too much during prolonged market downturns.

Potential drawbacks of fixed-percentage withdrawals

Because withdrawal amounts fluctuate with portfolio performance, retirees may experience inconsistent retirement income from year to year. Market volatility may reduce annual withdrawal amounts during periods of investment losses.

Are you a financial professional?

Explore retirement income insights, portfolio construction ideas, and client-ready planning resources designed for advisors.
Person seated on a bench using a smartphone and writing notesbeside a briefcase, paired with content promoting retirement resources for financial professional

What is a systematic withdrawal plan?

A systematic withdrawal plan is a retirement withdrawal strategy in which retirees withdraw investment income generated by a portfolio, such as dividends or interest payments, rather than taking a fixed dollar amount each year.

Some retirees use systematic withdrawal plans to help preserve their investment principal while still generating retirement income. However, the amount available for withdrawal may vary over time depending on market performance, interest rates and dividend payments.

Example of a systematic withdrawal strategy

Under a systematic withdrawal strategy, retirement income may rise or fall depending on the investment income generated by the portfolio.

Bar chart illustrating a systematic withdrawal strategy, with annual retirement income fluctuating from $38,745 to $48,600 over five years based on investment income generated by the portfolio.

For illustrative purposes only.

Why some retirees use systematic withdrawal plans

Systematic withdrawal plans may help retirees continue participating in long-term market growth while generating retirement income from portfolio investments. Some retirees also prefer this approach because it may reduce the need to sell investments during market downturns.

Potential drawbacks of systematic withdrawal plans

Investment income can fluctuate from year to year, which may create less predictable retirement income. Inflation may also reduce purchasing power over time if portfolio income does not keep pace with rising living costs.

What is a bucket strategy?

A bucket strategy is a retirement withdrawal approach that divides retirement savings into separate groups of assets based on when the money may be needed.

Under a bucket strategy, retirees may keep several years of living expenses in cash or cash equivalents while allocating other assets to fixed income investments and equities for longer-term growth potential.

For example:

  • A short-term bucket may hold cash for near-term spending needs
  • A middle bucket may hold fixed income investments
  • A long-term bucket may hold equities intended for future growth

As retirees spend assets from the short-term bucket, they may replenish it using earnings or growth from the other investment buckets.

Why some retirees use bucket strategies

Bucket strategies may help retirees balance short-term income needs with long-term growth potential. Some retirees also prefer this approach because maintaining cash reserves may reduce the need to sell investments during periods of market volatility.

Potential drawbacks of bucket strategies

Bucket strategies may require more ongoing monitoring and portfolio management than simpler withdrawal approaches. Changes in market conditions, inflation, and spending needs may also require retirees to adjust bucket allocations over time.

Combining retirement withdrawal strategies

Some retirees combine multiple retirement withdrawal strategies depending on income needs, market conditions, and financial goals. For example, retirees may use cash reserves for short-term expenses while relying on investment portfolios for long-term retirement income.

Retirement withdrawal strategies may also evolve over time as spending patterns, taxes, inflation, and investment performance change throughout retirement.

Retirement spending tools and resources

Retirement income planning tools may help retirees estimate spending needs, evaluate withdrawal strategies, and model retirement income over time.

The LifePath® Spending Tool is designed to help retirees estimate retirement spending potential using inputs such as age, retirement savings, portfolio allocation, and Social Security income estimates. The tool also incorporates life expectancy assumptions and long-term market projections to help retirees evaluate potential retirement income scenarios.

Frequently asked questions

  • The 4% rule is a retirement withdrawal strategy in which retirees withdraw 4% of retirement savings during the first year of retirement and adjust future withdrawals annually for inflation. The strategy is designed to help balance retirement income needs with long-term portfolio sustainability.

  • Required minimum distributions (RMDs) are mandatory withdrawals from certain tax-deferred retirement accounts beginning at age 73 under current IRS rules. RMDs generally apply to traditional IRAs and many employer-sponsored retirement plans.

  • Fixed-dollar withdrawals involve withdrawing the same dollar amount from retirement savings each year. Some retirees use this strategy to create more predictable retirement income and simplify budgeting.

  • Sequence-of-returns risk refers to the possibility that poor market performance early in retirement could reduce the longevity of a retirement portfolio. Large withdrawals during market downturns may make it more difficult for retirement savings to recover over time.

Want to learn more about saving for retirement?

Saving for retirement can be complicated – but it doesn’t have to be. Arm yourself with the information you need to make the best decisions for your financial future.
Saving for retirement can be complicated, click here to keep learning