LDI themes: The case for intermediate credit

June 2023 | By Elizabeth Perry

Traditionally, long corporate exposure has been the instrument of choice for pension plans, given its capital efficient nature (duration exposure per $ of assets) in hedging the overall duration target for the plan, particularly for underfunded plans or plans with a larger allocation to risk assets. As plans have become better funded and more mature, and valuations at the front-end of the yield curve have improved, we believe there could be potential for intermediate credit to provide both structural and tactical benefits to a corporate pension plan.

A new market environment

Higher interest rates have created an attractive entry point for liability hedging assets. This is particularly apparent at the front-end of the curve, where historically low term premia* is drawing investors towards the shorter or intermediate part of the curve.

This builds an increasingly compelling case for intermediate credit. As of 3/31/2023, the yield on the Bloomberg Long Corporate Index was 5.29% compared to 5.09% on the Bloomberg Intermediate Corporate Index, a difference of just 20bps. This compares to 3.10% yield for Long Corporate and 1.81% for Intermediate Corporate at the end of 2021 (12/31/2021), a difference of 129bps, highlighting the attractiveness of intermediate credit in the current market regime. Higher yields in general could also continue to bring more demand for fixed income and highly rated corporate credit risk.

*Source: Looking at 2s30s and 5s30s yield difference 1yr average compared to 10yr average as of 3/31/2023.

Time series of intermediate vs. long credit yields

Time series of intermediate vs. long credit yields

Source: BlackRock as of 03/31/23.Indexes are unmanaged, and one cannot invest directly in an index. Past performance does not guarantee future returns.

The structural case

There is also a structural argument for intermediate credit, to potentially better match exposure to the liability across different maturity buckets than solely using long duration corporate bonds.

We have seen a steady increase in average LDI allocations since 2009, with allocations increasing from an average of 37.1% in 2009 to an expected 52% on average in 2022*.

*Source: BlackRock, S&P Capital IQ as of 12/31/2021 Top 100 Corporate Pension Plans by size. BlackRock estimate for 2022 based on average asset allocation changes of BlackRock’s U.S. Corporate plan discretionary clients. Estimates are based on assumptions and there is no guarantee that they will be achieved.

This means that more pension assets are finding their way into fixed income investments, improving levels of available capital, and allowing plans to have more flexibility and targeted exposure by using both intermediate and long duration credit as building blocks. Adding intermediate credit could help plans that are looking to better match their key rate duration bucket exposure across the curve.

This could be particularly applicable for plans with higher fixed income allocations and frozen pension liabilities where the duration rolldown has resulted in a lower overall duration over time.

Additionally, plans that have a cash balance component in their liability modelling typically have a shorter overall plan duration which could result in the need to add shorter duration asset classes, implemented by including both intermediate government and intermediate corporate exposure.

A more custom allocation

Intermediate duration corporate exposure can be paired with other capital efficient investments, to build a custom allocation targeting overall duration, credit spread, and key rate duration hedging for a plan.

*There is no guarantee that these investment beliefs will work under all market conditions or are suitable for all investors. Each investor should evaluate their ability to invest long-term, especially during periods of downturn in the market. There is no guarantee that this will contribute to a positive outcome.

How Intermediate Credit Assets Contribute to KRD hedging

How Intermediate Credit Assets Contribute to KRD hedging

Source: BlackRock, for illustrative purposes only as of 12/31/2022. Current Portfolio modeled as 40% BBG Barclays U.S. Long Government Index, 40% BBG Barclays U.S. Long Corporate Index, and 20% growth asset modeled as MSCI World Index. Proposed portfolio consists of 35% Long Credit modeled as BBG Barclays US Long Credit Index, 22% Intermediate Credit modeled as BBG Barclays US Intermediate Credit Index, 5% Long Government modeled as BBG Barclays US Long Government Index, 8% Strips modeled as BBG Barclays STRIPS 20+ Index,10% Extended Duration Treasuries modeled as ICE Levered US Treasury Indices, 20% growth asset modeled as MSCI World Index. Liability modeled using a set of generic liability cashflows valued with the Bank of America Merrill Lynch AA-Rated US Corporate Market-Weighted Yield Curve with a duration of 12.7. The limitations of dollar durations are approximate, and result may vastly differ as due to estimations and fluctuation in bond values, rates, and payments and sensitive to interest rates changes. The funded status of the plan is assumed to be 100%. Models are for illustrative purposes only, hypothetical, based on assumptions, and subject to significant limitations. Models should not be relied upon as actual results may vary significantly. Indices are unmanaged and one cannot invest directly in an index.

In this example, we create a more diversified* portfolio by adding intermediate credit exposure and government bond exposure alongside the traditional long corporate and long government allocation. This could seek to improve the overall interest rate hedge ratio and key rate duration matching, in addition to adding diversification to the portfolio.

*Diversification does not assure a profit and may not protect against loss.

Looking ahead

Each pension plan is in a unique place with respect to their funded status, fixed income capital, and liability duration, among other considerations. Thematically, as both pension funding and market yields have shifted, this is leading many plan sponsors to re-evaluate their hedging exposures to ensure that they are aligned with their risk and return objectives.

Outside the scope of this paper, a potential next evolution of the intermediate spread conversation could span opportunities for intermediate spread exposure outside of the traditional corporate allocation. As plans mature and look to implement a more custom LDI investment solution, it’s time to re-evaluate the place for intermediate exposure within the toolkit.

Sign up to receive BlackRock's insights on LDI

Please click here to opt-in to receiving insight emails from BlackRock. Any data collected will be processed according to BlackRock's privacy policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

*Required information | Read our Privacy policy

Thank you for reaching out!

A BlackRock representative will reach out shortly. In the meantime, explore our website to read insights on the markets, portfolio design and more.


Explore our insights hub

Author

Elizabeth Perry, CFA
Director, Client Portfolio Manager